Labour’s 4 year plan ducks accountability on poverty, homes and basic services

19 Nov 2026
Merton Council

Merton Liberal Democrats tabled amendments to the Council’s new Borough Plan, demanding proper accountability and new measurable targets on breast cancer screening, local biodiversity and road safety.

The Borough Plan is produced every four years. It sets the Council’s aims and objectives and is meant to guide action.

The previous 2022-2026 Borough Plan promised 400 new council homes by 2026. That target was quietly watered down to “starting to build them”. No new Council homes have been built. Temporary accommodation costs remain stubbornly high.

The Leader of the Council effectively admitted the reason for previous failures, telling the meeting::

"Unlike borough plans that have gone before we're [now] laying the framework for how to make them a reality with clear targets and measurable outcomes"

And according to the End Child Poverty Coalition, around four in ten children in the Mitcham and Morden constituency still live in relative poverty after housing costs - nearly 12,000 children. The figure has barely moved in over a decade and remains one of the highest rates in London.

Speaking after the meeting, Cllr Anthony Fairclough, Leader of the Liberal Democrat Group, said:

“The previous borough plan’s big promises on homes and inequality simply were not delivered. Families are still waiting. Child poverty remains stubbornly high. And inequalities for young people with special educational needs and those leaving care persist.

“Residents will judge the Council by whether they can afford a home, whether they can access services, and whether their children have better opportunities.

“So there must be a relentless focus on improvement and delivery.

“I was pleased to hear the Leader of the Council admit the failure of previous Labour administrations to do this.

“That is why our central proposal was for an annual ‘State of the Borough’ report to Full Council, setting out clearly what has been achieved against every objective and target - and what has not. So that all councillors can focus on this core responsibility. If the administration is confident in its plan, it should be prepared to account for it in public in front of all councillors.”

The Liberal Democrats also proposed additional measurable targets that the 122-page plan still largely ignores:

  • Breast screening: Merton remains the only borough in South West London without a dedicated screening site, and almost one third of eligible women are overdue a check. The Lib Dems want a clear target to increase the number of potentially life-saving appointments.
  • Biodiversity: Developers are required to deliver a 10% biodiversity gain, but too often this is achieved by paying for projects miles away. The Lib Dems want more of that benefit kept in Merton for the communities affected by development.
  • Road safety: Entirely missing from the first draft until Lib Dem Cllr Richard Poole pressed for its inclusion in October. The Lib Dems now want targets to cut speeding and overweight vehicles, including HGVs, on Merton’s roads.
  • Council tax and charges: A cap to stop fees and Council Tax rising faster than inflation. Labour increased 257 Council charges above inflation last year - some by as much as 33%.

Cllr Fairclough added:

“The election results in May should prompt serious reflection by Labour Council bosses about their priorities and their relationship with residents.

“Nearly seven in ten voters chose someone else.

“That means there’s a huge need for a change in direction and real delivery, and a keenness to take on new ideas and work with others.

“The new borough plan needs to match the scale of residents’ expectations and show how it will actually be delivered - not Just be more ‘branded’ ambition.”

Cllr Richard Poole, Liberal Democrat Lead for Finance and Cost of Living, said:

“Zebra crossings, traffic lights, safe routes to school. Road safety is the bread and butter of local government, yet Labour’s first draft of this plan forgot about it entirely. It took Lib Dem councillors to put it back on the agenda, but simply counting road deaths is not enough.

“We need to tackle the problem at source by cutting the number of speeding drivers and overweight lorries thundering down our streets.”

ENDS

Notes:

  1. The debate can be seen on the Council’s YouTube here: https://www.youtube.com/live/qsT6-Tr7AhQ?t=7250s
  2. Full Council meeting, 18th November 2026. Agenda and papers (including amendments and the Borough Plan): democracy.merton.gov.uk/ieListDocuments.aspx
  3. Liberal Democrat amendments: page 5 of democracy.merton.gov.uk/documents/b17874/Supplementary%203%20-%20Amendments%20Wednesday%2018-Nov-2026%2019.30%20Council.pdf
  4. Cabinet meeting, 19th October 2026, where Cllr Richard Poole called for road safety to be included (05:40): youtu.be/D-xSJLlOlcU

This website uses cookies

Please select the types of cookies you want to allow.